How Much Do Custom Cakes Cost

Sharing is caring!

Last Updated on January 6, 2023

How much do custom cakes cost? First, it is best to remember that the costs of custom cakes vary from vendor to vendor and city to city. So with that, the custom cake price differs depending on their sizes, details of the requested customization, and complexity.

It would be best to choose a simple design since sophisticated customization costs more. That is why choose the least expensive basic flavor. Not only that but also maintain fewer slices based on the number of guests. Moreover, consider a square cake instead of a circular one because they are easier to cut and feed more guests. If you desire a tall cake, however, do not have the budget, consider adding non-cake decorated layers. For instance, Styrofoam or other materials.

How Much Do Custom Cakes Cost?

Keep in mind that specialty cake bakers know how to create excellent multitier custom cakes. In most cases, cakes are as much about appearance as how they taste. However, many professional bakers can guarantee both of those. Besides, they also know how to transport delicate cakes to clients’ venues safely.

So, it begs the question, how much are custom cakes? Professional bakers base their costs mainly on the number of people the cake requires to serve. But, it also includes the flavors, the number of tiers, and the complex designs. In addition to that, it is best to consider the delivery distance.

Custom Cakes Cost

Bear in mind, the taller the cake, the harder the task. Likewise, the more challenging the cake design, the higher the cost. For these reasons, it usually costs $100 for one-tier cakes and $200 for two-tier cakes. Additionally, it costs $300 for three-tier cakes and $400 for four-tier cakes. Furthermore, professional bakers charge a delivery fee to transport multitier cakes to their customer’s places safely. Thus, these fees commonly increase the farther the baker is from the location.

Considering The Number of Guests

Usually, it would help if you considered how many guests will be at a celebration. Likewise, it would be best if you took note of the cake slices needed for every guest. Not only but also other factors can affect the per-slice price. So with that, you can estimate the per serving by about $3.50.

Necessary Flavors and Ingredients

Remember, multi-flavor cakes cost more than organic cakes. In addition to that, the common flavor is vanilla and typically costs less than exotic flavors like red velvet. Also, buttercream is inexpensive. Therefore, it would be best to choose buttercream and fondant-buttercream. Besides, they are the two most common cake frostings. In that regard, it commonly costs $5 to $5.50 per slice for fondant and $4 to $4.50 for buttercream frosting.

LorAnn Super Strength Pack #4 of 12 Fruity Flavors in 1 dram bottles (.0125 fl oz – 3.7ml) bottles

Cake Prices: Custom Cakes Cost

  • Seven thousand eight hundred dollars for a 14″ x 5″ size with servings of twenty-six to thirty.

  • Six thousand eight hundred dollars for a 12″ x 5″ size with servings of twenty to twenty-six.

  • Five thousand five hundred dollars for a 10″ x 5″ size with servings of sixteen to twenty.

  • Four thousand five hundred dollars for a 9″ x 5″ size with servings of fourteen to sixteen.

  • Three thousand six hundred dollars for an 8″ x 5″ size with servings of twelve to fourteen.

  • Three thousand one hundred dollars for a 7″ x 5″ size with ten to twelve servings.

  • Two thousand five hundred dollars for a 6″ x 5″ size with eight to ten servings.

How Much Do Fake Wedding Cakes Cost?

The cost of fake wedding cakes depends on a variety of factors. If you’re looking to buy your dummy cake that you can decorate yourself, you can buy them in craft stores and online stores such as Oasis Supply; with prices starting at around $20. However, if you’re a novice, it may be quite difficult to decorate the cake.

It also depends on how many layers will be fake. Some people choose 1 or 2 layers to be dummies, and the rest to be real; this is to make the wedding cake look more extravagant than it is. You should get a professional to do this for you. It is cheaper to have dummy tiers, than all cake tiers, but again, it all depends on the cake flavors and fillings that you opt for. Completely dummy wedding cakes can start anywhere from $50-$1000+, depending on the complexity of the design and how many layers are fake/real.

How Much Does a Custom Cake Cost at Carlo’s Bakery?

Carlo’s Bakery is one of the most popular bakeries in the US and they’re often featured on the popular TV show Cake Boss. They offer a huge selection of custom cakes, for a range of different special occasions. For custom cakes, prices start at around $150. This is for single-tier 10-inch round cakes, that are relatively simple in design.

With these cakes, you can choose the flavor, base colors, and inscription. The flavors include vanilla rainbow, confetti, and chocolate fudge. For a more extravagant custom cake, you’ll be looking at around $300. This is for a two-tier cake with intricate designs. Again, you can choose the flavors, colors, and inscription.

How Much Does a Custom DQ Cake Cost?

Dairy Queen has a selection of custom cakes to choose from. They all cost a similar price and although you don’t get too much choice when it comes to personalizing the cakes, they are significantly cheaper than most places. Their Blizzard 8″ and 10″ cakes come in three different flavors: chocolate brownie, Oreo, and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. The 8″ cake is $26.99 and the 10″ cake is $30.99. For their standard cakes, they have many designs and styles to choose from.

You can often choose the colors of the cakes and choose a personalized message. The 8″ round cake is $23.99, the 10″ round cake is $27.99 and the sheet cake is $35.99. You’ll need to give around 2 days’ notice for these cakes.

How Long Does it Take to Make a Custom Cake?

The time to make a custom cake can vary massively; depending on who you choose to make it, the flavors, the fillings, the size, the occasion, etc. If you’re looking to buy a custom wedding cake, for example, you should give anywhere between 6-12 months’ notice to allow enough time for your cake maker to go through designs, cake testing sessions, etc.

For smaller occasion cakes like birthdays, the time frame is much smaller. Also, if you’re ordering from a store like Dairy Queen or Costco, you won’t have to wait long at all, as they churn their cakes out; whereas small businesses usually take much longer.

Should You Tip For a Custom Cake?

When it comes to custom cakes, you don’t typically need to tip your cake maker – it’s simply down to the individual. However, if the custom cake is for your wedding, wedding experts claim that it’s seen as good etiquette to tip both your cake maker and the delivery staff. The cake maker’s tip should be around 10% of the cost and the tip for delivery staff around $10-$20. You should also only do this if you’re happy with the service provided.

Tips When Ordering A Custom Cake

Essentially, it would be best to let the professional baker know what you are looking for; that is why you have to give as much information as possible. In addition to that, it is best to research in advance. With that, begin by giving a general idea or theme for your cake. After that, provide the essential details like colors and flavors. Moreover, it would be best to let the baker know the deadline for your cake and the number of guests. Besides, you can give other references like photos.

Most cakes from grocery stores are penny conscious and do not use good quality ingredients. For these reasons, do not base their prices on creating a good budget. So with that, it would be best to buy custom cakes at cake shops. Not only that but also, the cake will be baked for you. In addition to that, professional bakers will be able to concentrate on your custom cake.

When transporting a custom cake, make sure that you have space in your car for it. Finally, keep in mind that you must maintain the appropriate temperature for it at the venue or at home. Because of that, ensure that you ask your baker for proper storage and handling instructions. 

Facebook Comments

Sharing is caring!

Do you like this article? Share with your friends on Facebook.