What Colors Make Black Frosting: Making Pitch Black Icing

Sharing is caring!

Last Updated on February 10, 2023

What colors make black frosting? You need three parts of red food coloring; 2.5 parts of green food coloring and 1 part of blue food coloring. All you got to do is combine the colors and incorporate them well with your icing. After that, you have yourself an excellent base formula that should make black.

What Colors Make Black Frosting?

The colors that make black icing are red, green, and blue food coloring. You can use yellow food coloring as an alternative to green food coloring. However, it makes it harder to attain black since it is lighter. With that, begin with a small drop of each color. Make sure to stir them properly. And repeat the process till it becomes black. Remember to add even amounts of color.

Although, keep in mind that the actual color relies on the kind of food coloring you use and the ratio of food coloring to frosting. That is why you should pay careful attention to the resulting color once you have mixed it. Hence, modify it if required.

Moreover, you will need to put more of the color mixture if the color is a murky grey. You must also observe if one color red, green, or blue is standing out more than the rest. Because of that, it is best to put more of the other colors to balance the mixture. 

Black Icing

It is typically the go-to color when decorating cookies, cupcakes, or cakes for Halloween parties. In addition, it is usually the appropriate decoration for the most sophisticated cakes and cupcakes. May it be forming a solid black base on which you can layer various textures and colors or delicately piping onto the surface. Also, everything from black-and-white baked goods, like an elegant tiered cake, with black icing is a dessert that adds a level of aesthetic and prestige to any special occasion.

When creating vanilla black icing, you will have to put a big amount of black food coloring. Thus, it will greatly affect the flavor of the icing. Alternatively, you should add more cocoa powder if you only have vanilla icing available at home to make the icing appear darker in color.

12-Color Cake Food Coloring Set

It is also vital to remember that creating black food coloring needs a big amount of color since icings are all typically white at the start. It is also crucial to utilize gel or paste food coloring instead of liquid food coloring. For this reason, gel and paste food coloring are more concentrated in color. Likewise, they are less likely to change the consistency of the icing than liquid food coloring. 

Also, learn How To Make Dark Red Icing With Food Coloring

What is the Best Way to Color Black Icing?

Remember, it is always best to mix a little portion of color to experiment on a small dish bowl when combining colors red, green, and blue to make black icing. It is effective, especially if you are a beginner. 

Moreover, ensure to utilize a toothpick to add a small amount to obtain the correct shade of color. It is the best technique when blending colors. Thus, the icing color is incredibly concentrated, which provides icing with a rich coloring.

When it comes to the color black, you should add drops of red, green, and blue gel color. Then, completely mix it after every addition until the icing is near the desired color. Afterward, cover it and let it sit on the counter for about two to four hours. 

How Do You Make Dark Blue Icing Without Black?

Using a brand such as Color Light Concentrated is the best idea if you’re looking to make dark blue icing without using black food coloring. It depends on which shade of navy blue you’re looking for.

For example, if you’re looking for a light navy, start with 1 cup of white buttercream and add 13 drops of blue food coloring, 4 drops of red food coloring, and 2 drops of pink food coloring. Whereas if you want a deeper navy, start with 1 cup of white buttercream and add 26 drops of blue, 8 drops of red, and 4 drops of pink. And finally, for an intense dark navy, start with 1 cup of white buttercream and then add 52 drops of blue, 16 drops of red, and 8 drops of pink.

How to Make Dark Green Icing Without Black?

When making dark green icing, black food coloring is usually required. However, it doesn’t have to be! I use McCormick Liquid Food Coloring to achieve dark green icing, but any liquid food coloring can be used. To start with, you’ll need 1/2 cup of buttercream. Then add 24 drops of blue, 32 drops of green, and 4 drops of yellow. This is as dark as I’ve found you can get green icing without using black.

How to Get True Black Frosting?

When it comes to black frosting it’s always best to start with chocolate buttercream. This is because the darker the initial color, the easiest it is to make it darker. First, you’ll need to add darkened or black cocoa powder. Around 1/2 cup of this should be enough. It’s important not to add too much as this can change the taste of the frosting. The next step is to add a few drops of black gel food coloring. Using both of these should be enough to make your frosting black.

How Do You Make Black Frosting Taste Better?

Black frosting may not taste very nice if you do not carefully weigh out the ingredients you’re using. When it comes to adding cocoa powder, it can make the frosting taste chalky and gritty; that’s why it’s always best to start with small amounts and add more if you need to. When using black food coloring, it can become quite bitter tasting. For this reason, start slowly and work your way up. Only use minimal amounts to ensure it tastes better. If it still tastes bitter, you could try adding some melted chocolate chips to help make the frosting sweeter in flavor.

Why is My Black Icing Turning Green?

Sometimes the tint of your black icing will either look green or purple. You haven’t done anything wrong if this is the case – sometimes it just happens! If it turns green, try adding one drop of red food coloring. Mix well and then add more as needed. It will soon neutralize to black. The same goes with if your black icing is looking purple; add one drop of green food coloring and it should return to black. Again, add more if needed.

How Do You Make Dark Purple Icing With Food Coloring?

If you’re looking to make dark purple icing with food coloring alone, you’ll need a lot of red and blue! You’ll need around 30 drops of blue food coloring and around 130 drops of red food coloring, for every cup of buttercream. If you’re looking for a slightly lighter shade of purple, like grape, you’ll need around 20 drops of blue food coloring and 115 drops of red food coloring.

Tips and Tricks for How to Make Black Food Coloring

It is best to use black cocoa since it has a higher pH compared to Dutch-processed cocoa. Likewise, it is less acidic than natural baking cocoa. As a result, it will have an excellent dark color that provides an amazing chocolatey base for black icing. In addition to that, gel food coloring gives a super vibrant or deep shade to your icing. So, even if you add less of it, it can still result in a dark color.

Additionally, you can make black icing in advance. Not to mention that the color of the icing will get darker in the long run. Because of this, you can store it in the refrigerator till you need it. If you choose to do this, you should put it in an airtight container. With that, it can last for about a month in the fridge or, if you want, in the freezer, and you can store it for approximately three months.

Once thawed, it usually gets darker compared to when you initially made it. Also, remember to allow it to come to room temperature for a while before use. Furthermore, ensure to stir it properly once it thaws to achieve a smooth and fine consistency again.

Read more about What Colors Make Fuchsia Icing?

What Colors Make Grey Icing?

When it comes to making grey icing, the easiest way to achieve this is by using white icing and black gel food coloring. To effectively make this grey buttercream frosting, you’ll need the following ingredients:

• 1 cup of butter
• 4 cups of confectioners’ sugar
• 3 tablespoons of milk
• black gel food coloring

Now all you need to do is:

1. Add the following ingredients to a stand mixer: butter, sugar, and milk. Beat the mixture slowly at first, gradually making the speed faster. Once on high, beat for a few minutes.
2. Using a toothpick, add a small amount of black gel food coloring. Beat into the icing and keep mixing until you achieve the color you’re looking for, and your frosting is light and fluffy.
3. If your frosting is too thick, add a few drops of milk. If your frosting is too thin, add a tablespoon of confectioners’ sugar. Mix until you have achieved the consistency you’re looking for and use as needed.

What Two Colors Make Black Icing?

If you’re looking to make black icing not using gel black food coloring as a color, it is impossible to do with just two colors. If using black gel food coloring, you can simply add that bright white gel food coloring to your icing.

However, if you’re looking to achieve black icing without black food coloring, you’ll always need at least three colors: blue, green, and red.

How to Make Black Royal Icing

To make black royal icing, you’ll need the following ingredients:

• 4 cups of icing sugar
• 1/2 cup of water
• 3 tablespoons of meringue powder
• black gel food coloring – 1 teaspoon of coloring forever 1 cup of icing

Now all you need to do is:

1. Add the following ingredients to a bowl: sugar and meringue powder. Starting on a low speed, mix well until no lumps remain.
2. Still on a low speed, pour in the water and keep mixing until completely combined. You should mix for around 5 minutes to achieve soft peaks.
3. If your icing seems too thin, just keep mixing. If it seems too thick, add a teaspoon of water and mix well.
4. Using a toothpick, add a small amount of black gel food coloring. Instead of using a stand mixer, use your hand instead. Add more black using your toothpick, until you reach the color you’re looking for.

NOTE: If you want to make this icing with cocoa powder, make your white icing using the recipe above, and then add around 3 teaspoons of cocoa powder. Mix well and then add a toothpick-sized amount of black food coloring to deepen the color.

Natural Black Food Coloring

There are two easy ways to achieve black food coloring using natural ingredients. The best options are activated charcoal or black cocoa powder.

When using charcoal, grab a bowl and add one teaspoon of charcoal to every 1/2 tablespoon of hot water. Mix well and then gradually add to your icing until you have achieved the color you’re looking for.

When using black cocoa, the ratio should be 3 parts water to 1 part black cocoa. Mix well and then add to your icing. You may need to add a small amount of butter to remove the bitter flavor.

Conclusion

I hope this post has helped to answer the question: what colors make black frosting? And also gives you an idea of ways you can make your own from natural black food coloring. Do you have any tips or tricks when it comes to making black frosting? If so, please feel free to let me know in the comments below. Sharing is caring!

Sharing is caring!