Can Pecan Pie Be Frozen? 5 Helpful Tips!

Sharing is caring!

Last Updated on January 24, 2023

Can pecan pie be frozen? Yes, pecan pie is an amazing dessert to make in advance. Freezing your pecan pie in advance will save you time in the long run. 

All you have to do is to bake the pie as instructed and let it cool entirely. Afterward, wrap with plastic wrap, put it in an airtight container, and freeze it up for three months. However, there are also some other helpful tips for baking and freezing the best pecan pie possible. 

Likewise, making pies ahead of time and freezing them is ideal, especially when preparing for Thanksgiving. However, you may encounter freezer burns along the way. That is why knowing how to freeze pecan pie correctly is the best way to ensure the pie’s texture and flavor will not be affected.

While many bakers may ask themselves can pecan pie be frozen, it is reassuring that this popular dessert can be frozen. In fact, it is one of the best desserts to make in advance and freeze. 

Can Pecan Pie Be Frozen?

Pecan pie is a delicious dessert perfect for any holiday. However, you may wonder, can pecan pie be frozen? Fortunately, you can make your pecan pie up to four months in advance, saving you precious time around the holidays. 

There are some helpful tips you should know before freezing your pecan pie to ensure that it still tastes delicious when served. While it does freeze well if proper steps are not taken it can get freezer burn or can lose its quality. 

How to Freeze Pecan Pie

Before you freeze the pecan pie, ensure to let the pie cool entirely. Doing this avoids freezer burn and preserves the texture. Make sure to prepare the pie correctly since the filling will take on a different flavor or texture if not prepped properly. 

Wrap the pecan pie with plastic wrap once completely cooled. Ensure to cover it entirely with no open gaps since it will allow the air to enter the pie. Because of that, you want to maintain the pie entirely secure from the contact of air. You can also wrap it in small slices individually if you prefer not to thaw the whole pie at once because it is ideal for lunch boxes and snacks.

Do not freeze if the filling seeped through the crust or the crust is still moist after baking since there is a possibility that the crust will become soggy after thawing. If this happens, it cannot be corrected.

Preferably, it is best to freeze a pre-baked pie crust and add the pie filling to bake on the day you are serving it. It is also ideal to use a pecan pie recipe not containing eggs when freezing homemade pecan pie.

Here are some tips on What To Do With Pie Crusts?

Helpful Tips for Freezing Pecan Pie

Now that we have answered the question “can pecan pie be frozen?” there are some helpful tips to ensure your pie will be as tasty as possible. While pecan pie can be frozen, don’t skip these tips as they will make a difference when freezing pecan pie. 

Tip One: Give Plenty of Time to Cool

Allow your pecan pie plenty of time to cool before you place it in the freezer. If it is still warm when you place it in the freezer you risk the chance of changing the consistency due to the drastic temperature difference.

Allow your pecan pie to cool on a wire rack fully before freezing. To help speed up the process, you can place your pie near a window cracked open. It will likely take an hour or more for your pie to fully cool so be patient and don’t rush the process.

Tip Two: Don’t Skimp on the Wrapping

When wrapping your pecan pie, don’t skimp on the plastic wrap as this could cause freezer burn. You ideally want to wrap two to three layers of plastic wrap over your pecan pie to ensure that it is fully covered.

You can also wrap it in a layer of aluminum foil after a layer of plastic wrap. However, you typically want to avoid only wrapping in aluminum foil with no plastic wrap as it may lead to freezer burn.

Tip Three: Wait to Add the Toppings

Pecan pie tastes delicious when paired with various toppings. You can add whipped cream, caramel sauce, and even ice cream to your pecan pie. However, hold off adding your toppings to your pie until after it is thawed, as they will interfere with the thawing process of your pie.

Tip Four: Add the Date

Don’t forget to add the date to your pecan pie when freezing it. It can be easy to make your pie ahead of time and freeze it, only to forget how long it has been in the freezer.

By adding the date you will know exactly how long your pie has been in the freezer, which is helpful as it will lose its flavor and consistency over time. You can use a Sharpie to write directly on the plastic wrap or write the date on masking tape and then put the tape on the pie’s covering. 

Tip Five: Store the Pie Flat 

To ensure your pie maintains its shape, store it flat in your freezer. In addition, avoid stacking items on your pecan pie as this may damage it. 

What is Pecan Pie?

Pecan pie is a sweet, buttery pie crust loaded with pecan nuts combined with a pie filling of corn syrup, eggs, and butter. It is a delicious dessert for celebrations, tea time, and holidays. You can purchase it in various sizes at grocery stores and bakeries, or you can make it at home. It comes in a variety of sizes like bite-size tartlets, mini-pies, and large pies.

Why is Pecan Pie a Great Freezer-Friendly Dessert?

Pecan pie is a perfect dessert when preparing for a big event, especially to reduce the holiday madness. Its high sugar-fat mixture and low water content freeze better than any other kind of pie. Likewise, the butter and corn syrup maintains the pie’s moisture and prevent it from becoming soggy on thawing.

Check this recipe Choc-Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

Can Pecan Pie Be Frozen and Can You Freeze Leftover Pecan Pie?

 Moreover, defrosting and refreezing a leftover pecan pie a second time will degrade the ingredients. Likewise, once the pecan pie has been frozen and thawed, you cannot refreeze the pie, or else there will be changes in flavor and texture.

Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips

How to Thaw Pecan Pie Properly

Ensure that no pie filling has leaked onto the plastic wrap when taking the pecan pie out of the freezer. If anything has leaked onto the wrapping, take off the plastic wrap immediately and replace it with a single clean layer so that the extra moisture does not mess up the pie texture. Afterward, rewrapping it is essential.

The night before, transfer the pecan pie from the freezer to the refrigerator. Please put it on the counter, enabling it to come to room temperature. Afterward, leave the pecan pie to thaw entirely before reheating. Then, preheat your oven to 350 degrees Farenheit and heat the pecan pie in the oven for around 10 minutes to crisp the crust and warm it slightly without baking it further. 

Moreover, frozen pecan pie has an estimated shelf life of four months or more in the freezer. It is not suggested to wait this long before eating the pie to lessen any texture or flavor changes. 

How Long Does Pecan Pie Last?

Pecan pie can last for about three to four days in the fridge and about four months in the freezer. You have to consider the moisture and egg since the texture will not be the same if it lasts long after you have frozen it. Likewise, if not frozen and thawed properly, it will have the consistency of a cereal left in milk for too long.

How to Know If Pecan Pie is Spoiled?

The pecan pie is spoiled if it appears mushy and moldy. Also, check if it is smelling funky or has an off-smelling aroma. If this is the case, then it is time to discard the pecan pie.

Can Pecan Pie Be Frozen? How to Do it Right 

After this article, you won’t have to ask yourself, can pecan pie be frozen? By following the helpful tips above you can successfully freeze your pecan pie to enjoy at a later time. This can make planning for the holidays much easier while also saving you time and stress in the kitchen. 

I hope this information has been helpful, if so be sure to share this article! 

Sharing is caring!