How To Fix Jello That Did Not Set Properly

Sharing is caring!

Last Updated on February 18, 2023

How To Fix Jello That Did Not Set Properly? Essentially, you prepare jello by blending the supplied gelatin with boiling water. Then, add cold water. After that, you store it in the fridge to set it for several hours. 

For the most part, it seems like an easy process. But, keep in mind that there are indeed numerous ways you can mess it up. Though do not worry, because I can guarantee you approaches to prevent them from happening. 

Always remember that you have to mix according to package instructions. After that, you have to chill it for the jello to set. If it did not work, then that could mean you have added plenty of water. Likewise, you have added fruits with an abundant amount of water content. 

You can fix jello by mixing a cup of boiling water with a three oz box of jello. Keep in mind that it has to have similar flavors. Afterward, make sure to whisk it till you have dissolved the jello. After that, stir it into your not-set jello recipe. Then, make sure to store it in the fridge till it sets. 

How To Fix Jello That Did Not Set Properly?

For starters, you can always try salvaging it. But, if you cannot save it, you will need to redo the entire process. With that, dissolve the gelatin in boiling water. Make sure to do this before adding cold water to the mix. Keep in mind that this applies when you are preparing it from scratch. 

Also, if the gelatin does not dissolve well before you added the cold water, it will indeed not set. Afterward, ensure to cover the jello with cling wrap. Do this if you intend to let it rest overnight. Not only that, but also it will stop the jello from hardening and enable it to set.  

Remember, ensure to remove all the fruits to prevent the jello from setting. The main reason is that fruits like pineapple, papaya, and kiwi have an enzyme. Because of that, it breaks down the gelatin. Besides that, it prevents it from setting. 

Then, make sure to pick out fruits from the jello till it starts to thicken. Bear in mind that the jello must stay in the fridge for approximately one and a half hours. For that reason, ensure to do this before you remove the fruits. Also, ensure to drain canned vegetables and fruits. 

How Can I Make Jello Set Faster? 

Essentially, gelatin is seventy percent protein. And it produces a chain matrix between gelatin molecules in the dessert that holds the liquid. In addition to that, it provides the dessert or pudding with an appropriate shape that you can unmold. 

Moreover, know that gelatin and sugar both compete for water. For that reason, the correct quantity of sugar will supply a softer dessert. Not only that but also a shorter chain. Keep in mind that you have to combine the sugar with gelatin. Do this before you add the water or other liquids. The main reason is that the jelly usually has sugar blended with gelatin before cooking. That is why this process typically works best. 

30 PCS/SET Flowers Leaves 3D Jelly Art Tools Cake Jello art Gelatin Tools pudding nozzle

Before anything else, you have to dissolve the gelatin mix in three-fourths cup boiling water. After that, add ice to a half cup of cold water to make 1 1/4 cups. Then, make sure to stir the cold water into the gelatin till it thickens. Finally, ensure to remove any unmelted ice. And refrigerate for thirty to ninety minutes. Likewise, you can put it in the fridge till it is firm. 

Jello Desserts

Essentially, jello does not have any gluten in the ingredients. That is why you can consider it gluten-free. Also, keep in mind that jello is an exciting addition to any table. So with that, here are different jello recipes. 

Pretzel Jello Dessert 

You will love this kind of jello dessert! Keep in mind that its salty pretzel crust is an excellent complement to the sweet cream cheese filling. 

Stained Glass Gelatin – How To Fix Jello That Did Not Set Properly

Your children will love its wiggly and sweet gelatin. Not only that but also its whipped topping dessert is exceedingly delicious! Though, do not be afraid to use various gelatin flavors. 

Seven-Layer Gelatin Salad 

It is an eye-catching dessert that you will love to make for Christmas every year. In addition to that, you can select diverse flavors to make other color blends for gatherings and holidays. 

Rainbow Gelatin Cubes

Extremely fun to serve and eat! And you will enjoy the different colors to suit the occasion. 

Flavors Of Jello

Jello has various delectable flavors you can choose from, such as berry blue, apricot, blackberry, and black cherry. In addition to that, it has a cherry, cherry lemonade, and blackberry fusion. Here are other jello flavors: 

• Cotton candy 
• Grape 
• Lemon
• Lime 
• Mango 
• Margarita
• Orange 
• Pineapple 
• Strawberry 
• Concord grape 
• Fruit punch 
• Green apple 
• Lemon-lime 
• Mango 
• Melon fusion 
• Peach 
• Raspberry 
• Strawberry-banana 

How Do You Recook Jelly That Didn’t Set?

To recook your jelly that didn’t cook, mix one tablespoon of powdered pectin and one cup of water in a saucepan. Allow the mixture to come to a boil while stirring constantly and then remove it from the heat.

Pour the mixture into your jelly and add two tablespoons of sugar to every cup of jelly. Return to the stove and bring the jelly mixture to a boil, stirring constantly.

Allow the mixture to boil for 30 seconds before removing it from the heat. Then, skim off the foam and add it to your hot sterilized jars. Then seal the jars and process for five minutes in a boiling water bath.

If you have liquid pectin, add three tablespoons of sugar, 1 1/2 teaspoons of lemon juice, and 1 1/2 teaspoons of liquid pectin together and combine. Add your jelly to a saucepan and bring to a boil then remove from the heat.

Then add your liquid pectin mixture to your jelly and return to the stove, bringing it to a boil while stirring constantly. Boil for one minute and then remove from the stove. Fill your jars and process as per the original recipe instructions.

How Many Times Can You Reboil Jelly?

Ideally, you do not want to reboil jelly more than a couple of times. It is recommended to wait at least 24 to 48 hours to allow your jelly to set before reboiling it.

When reboiling jelly, do not reboil more than eight cups at one time. Ideally, you want to keep it to four to six cups of jelly at a time when working with it.

To reboil jelly without using pectin, add 1 1/2 teaspoons of lemon juice per every cup of jelly. Then add your jelly to a saucepan and bring it to a boil. Then after reaching a boil, remove the jelly from the heat.

After that, skim the jelly and pour it immediately into sterilized jars. Then be sure to seal your jars and process for five minutes.

Can You Warm Up Jelly?

You can warm up your jelly to add to different foods such as bread, pancakes, waffles, English muffins, and more. You can warm up the jelly on the stovetop or in the microwave. You can even add it to baked goods such as pastries or use it as fillings in cakes.

Only warm up the amount of jelly you need when you go to warm it up. While it is safe to warm up jelly, it may not form a gel once again when heating as the over-cooking of pectin, an ingredient in jelly, can reduce or destroy its ability to hold a gel structure.

Can You Heat Jello Instant Pudding?

It is not recommended to heat jello instant pudding as it is not designed to be heated up. It can change the consistency of instant pudding and it will not be as desirable to eat. Be sure to make your instant pudding according to the instructions on the packet.

Tips And Tricks On How To Fix Jello That Did Not Set Properly

Do not utilize frozen and fresh fruits that have the enzyme that breaks down the gelatin. Besides, it is best to refrigerate the jello for approximately four hours. 

Furthermore, it would help to add only one and a half times the quantity of salt. You can include other wet ingredients that the recipe needs. Take note of these when preparing twice the amount of jello. Besides that, ensure to add twice the quantity of fruit, liquid, and gelatin when doubling the recipe. However, never ration other ingredients like salt or lemon juice. 

Moreover, it provides fruit addition recommendations on the side of the box of jello. You can indeed use any fruits you want, though you have to lessen the water. You can do this with a half cup in your recipe. 

Also, note that it will be more jelly-like and softer if you use sufficient sugar in the gelatin. Additionally, you have to hydrate gelatin crystals in lukewarm water or other warm liquids, such as juices or milk. Doing this ensures that the crystals’ edges will absorb the water. Though, make sure to keep stirring at intervals till it dissolves. 

Read more about How To Keep Jello From Sticking? 4 Easy Steps That Will Result In Success

Sharing is caring!